Case study · QiQ Platform
Beyond the contact center: How QiQ uncovered the root causes of customer dissatisfaction and up to $11.5M in potential annual value
Despite strong customer satisfaction and operational performance, a leading home retailer struggled to understand why customers were unlikely to recommend its brands. Using QiQ, Quantanite analyzed customer interactions and public reviews to identify the underlying causes of dissatisfaction, revealing opportunities to improve retention, reduce avoidable contacts and unlock an estimated $6.2M to $11.5M in annual business value.
The client
America's leading online home retailer
A leading North American online home retailer, generating more than $1 billion in annual sales, serves millions of customers across two established retail brands.
With a broad portfolio of furniture, homeware and outdoor products, the business manages complex customer interactions involving delivery, returns, product quality, and order fulfillment.
Quantanite supports the retailer's customer service operations, handling approximately 20,000 calls per month across returns, order tracking, replacement parts, purchasing assistance and cancellations.
The challenge
Customers remained significantly less likely to recommend the brands
Despite exceeding key customer service performance targets, the retailer faced a persistent challenge. Customer satisfaction and case productivity were both above target, yet customer advocacy remained well below expectations.
Traditional quality assurance processes provided limited visibility into the reasons behind this disconnect. Of more than 60,000 cases closed during the quarter, just 482 detractor interactions were manually reviewed.
Existing analysis suggested that most dissatisfaction stemmed from issues outside agents' control. However, the retailer lacked the insight to identify which policies, processes and product issues were driving customer frustration, quantify their business impact and prioritize improvements.
The business needed to move beyond measuring contact center performance to understanding the root causes of customer dissatisfaction.
The solution
QiQ analyzed every detractor call, revealing patterns echoed in public reviews
Quantanite used QiQ, its AI-powered decision intelligence platform, to analyze 102 detractor calls alongside 61 negative public reviews.
Rather than focusing solely on agent performance, QiQ identified recurring customer issues, traced dissatisfaction to underlying causes and connected findings to potential commercial impact.
The analysis revealed seven recurring themes across customer calls and public reviews, including return policies, order cancellations, product discrepancies and unresolved service issues.
QiQ then quantified and prioritized opportunities based on their potential impact on revenue, customer retention, operational costs and business risk, identifying the functions best positioned to address them.
Two sources, analyzed fully. Every recording in the August cohort transcribed and matched to the QA tracker, alongside 61 one and two-star reviews from the same window.
Every call and every review scored on the same nine customer measures, each one attributed to a cause and logged with how serious it was.
The two sources compared, theme by theme. Seven problems appeared in both, showing that a complaint made on the phone was already sitting in public.
Each problem priced against order value, the risk of losing the customer and the cost of the contact, then ranked by what it was costing.
A named fix for each problem, from moving fraud screening to checkout through to tracked callbacks, each handed to the team that can make it.
The findings
93% of detractor calls revealed issues beyond agent control
QiQ found that 95 of 102 detractor calls were primarily driven by issues outside the agent's control, including business policies, product quality, and operational processes.
Nearly half of these interactions received the lowest possible customer score, despite agents often following established procedures.
This revealed a critical disconnect: customer feedback was exposing systemic business problems that traditional agent-focused quality assurance could not resolve.
What it cost, by what the call was about
The pattern is counter-intuitive and it is the most commercially useful finding. Delivery failures were the largest volume problem. Policy was the most expensive one.
| What the call was about | Calls | Average score /10 | Said they would stop buying |
|---|---|---|---|
| Delivery and fulfillment | 68 | 1.9 | 7% |
| Policy and return fees | 29 | 1.0 | 28% |
| Price, value, listing | 19 | 3.1 | 5% |
| Billing and refunds | 17 | 2.0 | 0% |
| All detractor calls | 102 | 10% |
A policy dispute loses a customer four times as often as a delivery failure, 28% against 7%, even though delivery was the larger volume.
Four areas emerged as significant opportunities for improvement
Among customers disputing return fees, 28% expressed an intention to stop purchasing, compared with 7% of customers experiencing delivery issues.
One customer paid $158 to send back six rugs they had tried at home, within policy. The fee is what they said they were leaving over, and customers are raising the same issue in public.
“The partial refund is $37. That won't even cover one chair.”
“To have to pay for returns is disgusting!”
QiQ identified opportunities to reduce churn risk through clearer return-cost information, more flexible policies and greater agent discretion.
Nearly 9% of analyzed calls involved orders blocked, canceled or at risk, including high-value purchases.
An order of roughly $1,100 was flagged for a billing and shipping name mismatch and canceled the day before delivery, without notice to the customer. It was re-verified and placed again on the call, three departments later.
“I probably won't ever use [the retailer] again.”
“Order was cancelled due to some stupid reason stating that it was a potential fraud.”
QiQ highlighted opportunities to recover sales through earlier fraud verification, improved promotional processes and better support for bulk buyers.
Customers reported damaged furniture, missing components and products that did not match their online descriptions.
In one case, a customer whose couch frame failed found engineered plywood where the listing described hardwood, and used the words federal law violation. Two public reviews in the same week raised the same material claim.
“This is a bait and switch. You did not sell me the product I paid for.”
“only one little piece on top was pine, the rest was MDF.”
QiQ identified opportunities to improve product-listing accuracy, strengthen supplier quality controls and reduce potential compliance and reputational risks.
Nearly one-third of analyzed calls involved repeat contacts or interactions that ended before the issue was resolved.
Of 33 such calls, the 22 that ended mid-issue averaged 0.5 out of 10. A promise made on the call depends on the warehouse, claims, carriers and card partners to keep it.
“It's now August. I've been dealing with this for 3 months.”
“Promised a response in two days. No response for six days.”
QiQ identified opportunities to reduce unnecessary contact volume through stronger follow-up processes, clearer accountability and improved coordination across business functions.
Seven of the 102 calls were attributable to Quantanite, and each now has a fix in place.
Where agents had room to resolve an issue outright, the outcome changed.
“You've been the best person I've talked to so far.”
Customer, on a call where a return fee was waived
Interactions like this one sat within the same detractor cohort, where an agent was able to waive a fee or arrange a collection without seeking approval. QiQ identified opportunities to extend that discretion, one of the lowest-cost improvements available to the business.
The value
$6.2M to $11.5M a year in revenue recovered, customers kept and cost avoided
By connecting customer friction to its potential financial impact, QiQ identified four areas of opportunity.
| Opportunity | Estimated annual value |
|---|---|
| Recovering at-risk orders and sales | $2.4M to $4.2M |
| Reducing policy-driven customer churn | $1.8M to $3.1M |
| Eliminating avoidable customer contacts | $1.1M to $1.9M |
| Reducing product quality and listing risks | $900K to $2.3M |
| Total potential annual value | $6.2M to $11.5M |
Ten customers told an agent they would stop buying. Eight of them over a fee.
These figures represent modeled annual opportunities, not realized financial outcomes. Actual value will depend on implementation and validation against broader business data.
Results
Improving customer advocacy while identifying opportunities for greater impact
Alongside the QiQ analysis, Quantanite continued to strengthen customer service performance. Between June and August 2026:
Likelihood to recommend increased 62%, from 12.4% to 20.1%.
Customer satisfaction reached 86.9%, exceeding the 71% target.
Case close rate reached 79.3%, well above the 60% target.
While these operational improvements were achieved during the same period, QiQ revealed opportunities to address the broader business issues affecting customer experience and commercial performance.
| Metric | Target | June 2026 | July 2026 | August 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Likelihood to recommend | 45% | 12.4% | 16.3% | 20.1% |
| Customer satisfaction | 71% | 84.7% | 85.3% | 86.9% |
| Case productivity | 65% | 79.8% | 84.9% | 84.5% |
| Case close rate | 60% | 77.9% | 78.5% | 79.3% |
| After-call work | 12% | 9.5% | 10.2% | 10.7% |
What's next
Turning one month of calls into a loop of fixes and measurement
The next phase will focus on translating QiQ's findings into measurable business improvements across three priorities.
Return costs shown before checkout, label fees capped on bulky items, material claims audited across furniture listings, hardware QC on the flat-pack lines named in the read, and every promised callback tracked to closure in QiQ.
Fraud screening moved to checkout with verification before cancellation, promotional codes issued in session rather than by email, samples offered on wallpaper and textiles, and one front door across both brands.
QiQ runs across full monthly volume rather than detractors alone, widens the public record beyond one platform, takes in the four client inputs needed to price the opportunity, and reports weekly on where calls and reviews agree and what moved.
FAQ
How QiQ identifies commercial value in customer operations
What is QiQ?
QiQ is Quantanite's AI-powered decision intelligence platform. It analyzes customer interactions to uncover the root causes of customer demand, quantify their financial impact and help businesses prioritize the actions that will deliver the greatest value.
How did QiQ identify up to $11.5M in potential annual business value?
QiQ analyzed 102 detractor calls and 61 public reviews, identifying recurring issues affecting customer retention, revenue and operating costs. Each call was attributed to a cause and sized against order value, retention risk and contact cost. The result was four levers: $2.4M to $4.2M in commercial order recovery, $1.8M to $3.1M in policy-driven churn, $1.1M to $1.9M in avoidable contact cost, and $900K to $2.3M in quality and listing risk.
What did QiQ reveal about the cause of customer dissatisfaction?
QiQ found that 93% of analyzed detractor calls were primarily driven by issues beyond agent control, including business policies, product problems and operational processes. This revealed opportunities to improve customer experience by addressing underlying business issues rather than focusing solely on agent performance.
How is QiQ different from traditional contact center quality assurance?
Traditional QA typically evaluates a sample of customer interactions, focusing on agent performance and process adherence. QiQ goes further, analyzing customer interactions to identify systemic issues, quantify their business impact and help prioritize improvements across the organization.
Find the root causes behind your own customer dissatisfaction
Send us a sample of past customer interactions. QiQ analyzes them alongside your public reviews to identify the policies, processes and product issues driving dissatisfaction, quantify their potential business impact and prioritize the changes worth making first.